If you’re living in Forest Hill, North Ward, or anywhere near the Branch Brook Park area, El Caribe Supermarket at 686-696 Mt Prospect Ave is the local heart and soul for keeping your kitchen stocked. Located right in the middle of our historic neighborhood, it’s the go-to spot for those of us who would rather grab fresh ingredients at a place with real character than deal with the massive, impersonal lines at the big-box stores. It’s a busy, high-energy market, but it still has that "neighborhood marqueta" feel where you’re treated like a regular from the second you walk in.
What really makes "El Caribe" a legend in Newark is the Hot Food Counter. If you’re looking for the best Dominican and Spanish food in the city, this is it. We’re talking about massive plates of pernil (roast pork), rice and beans, and mofongo that taste exactly like they came out of a family kitchen. It’s a total lifesaver for those days when you’re too tired to cook but still want a real, home-style meal. The prices are a steal for the amount of food they pile on, and the smell of the rotisserie chicken hitting the air is enough to make anyone a regular.
The Meat and Produce selection is another reason this spot is an anchor for the community. Their carniceria (butcher shop) is top-tier; whether you need a specific cut for a Christmas pork roast or just some fresh chicken for a weeknight stew, the butchers here actually know their stuff. You’ll also find all the essential Latin products that the bigger chains usually skip—everything from specialty seasonings and plantains to authentic tropical fruits. It’s that mix of "everything you need" and "hard-to-find favorites" that makes a grocery run here so much better than the average store.
For those of us with a busy North Ward schedule, the convenience and friendly vibe are what seal the deal. It’s clean, the staff is respectful and hardworking, and they keep the energy upbeat even when the after-work rush is in full swing. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick cup of coffee and a pastry in the morning or doing a full weekly haul for the family, El Caribe is the reliable, no-nonsense spot that keeps the neighborhood running. It’s more than just a supermarket; it’s where Forest Hill goes to eat well and feel at home.
Business Hours
Monday – Saturday: 8:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Sunday: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM (Note: The hot food counter is usually at its peak around lunchtime and early evening, so if you’re looking for that fresh roast pork, try to get there before the dinner rush!)
